Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-05-12 Thread Weiwei Yang
Hi all Recently we had a lot of discussions, and thanks for everyone sharing the thought in the google form. Really helpful. Please see the result: [image: The_Next_YuniKorn_Release__0_11_or_1_0_-_Google_Forms.png] even we have slightly more people who prefer to release the 1.0 version, we do see

Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-28 Thread Julia Kinga Marton
Hi Everyone! I think the safest way for now is to go with 0.11 for the next release. Right now I think we have a stable and tested version of YuniKorn, but also have some bigger things ongoing, as were there were mentioned before, such as the REST API changes, and interface changes. I would

Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-22 Thread Wilfred Spiegelenburg
On Fri, 23 Apr 2021 at 04:00, Weiwei Yang wrote: > Hi Wilfred > > Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Please see my comments below: > > We are cleaning up the scheduler interface and moving things around for the > > API in the next release. > > > I assume you are referring to >

Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-22 Thread Weiwei Yang
Hi Wilfred Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Please see my comments below: We are cleaning up the scheduler interface and moving things around for the > API in the next release. I assume you are referring to https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/YUNIKORN-486. Removing some unused protobuf

Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-22 Thread Wilfred Spiegelenburg
Weiwei, We are cleaning up the scheduler interface and moving things around for the API in the next release. We are also about to make major changes to the REST interface. Settling those and making sure we have that all correct is I think required before we do a 1.0 release, not as part of a 1.0

Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-21 Thread Weiwei Yang
Hi Bowen Thanks for sharing your thoughts. There is no standard for what 1.0 release means. IMO, we can refer to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Software_versioning#Version_1.0_as_a_milestone . Having 1.0 release indicates the software has the major features ready, the public APIs are stabilized,

Re: Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-21 Thread Bowen Li
Hi Weiwei, Thanks for bringing up this discussion. That may depend on what "1.0" means, and what bumping a major version means. Usually a new major version (e.g. 0.x -> 1.x -> 2.x) contains some critical new features or breaking changes. One critical feature of the next release is integration

Next YuniKorn release discussion - the next step

2021-04-21 Thread Weiwei Yang
Hi all In today's community meeting, we have started the discussion for the next release. About the release version, we have 2 candidates: *0.11* or *1.0*. Which one should be our next release? I would like to bring this up to more people's attention and hear more thoughts from you. The project