Re: [DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-26 Thread Jongyoul Lee
Hi Jagat, I'd love to listen how users use Apache Zeppelin in real world. It always help to figure out what we have to focus on, to find out what the critical issues are and to set the future roadmap. Can you share us - or me - detail issues bothering you? On Wed, Feb 22, 2017 at 5:28 PM, Jagat S

Re: [DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-23 Thread Jagat Singh
We are implementing the exact same use case today , Trying out central shared zeppelin 0.7 instance in our organisation. As member of admin team we have locked down the interpreter page and published set of settings which we have been configured in the backend. If Interpreter settings are per use

Re: [DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-22 Thread Jongyoul Lee
Yes, we can set some roles by Shiro but what I mean is we didn't implement role-based functions like hiding or showing some menu. On Thu, Feb 23, 2017 at 12:17 PM, Prabhjyot Singh wrote: > Yes, agreed we need some components to manage lifecycle of interpreters. > > > "I agree that we need to ke

Re: [DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-22 Thread Prabhjyot Singh
Yes, agreed we need some components to manage lifecycle of interpreters. > "I agree that we need to keep same behavior even though users restart in any place." I too agree we should have same behaviour. > Thus we must not assume that "admin" exists. In Zeppelin we can do this https://github.com

Re: [DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-22 Thread Jongyoul Lee
Basically, I agree that we need to keep same behavior even though users restart in any place. I don't have any preference between restarting all processes and starting user's process but currently Zeppelin doesn't have any "admin" feature and no concept like admin by default. Thus we must not assum

Re: [DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-22 Thread Jeff Zhang
I think we can combine scenario 2 and 3 if user click yes button on the popup window of whether you want to restart interpreter in scenario 3. Regarding the restarting scenario of 1,2,3, IMHO I think we don't need to differentiate them. Otherwise it might confuse users that restarting in different

[DISCUSS] Behaviour of Interpreter when it is restarted

2017-02-22 Thread Prabhjyot Singh
This is WRT the PR that I've created https://github.com/apache/zeppelin/pull/2034. The issue that I want to discuss over here is how should an Interpreter behave when it is; - restarted from notebook - restarted from Interpreter setting page - edited from Interpreter setting page - deleted fro