Re: Bump minimum required Java version for building ZK to 11

2025-08-19 Thread Andor Molnar
We cannot upgrade Jetty if we stay on JDK11, which is my biggest concern about it. > On Aug 19, 2025, at 19:11, Christopher wrote: > > Sorry for the confusion. I linked that PR mostly for my own reference > to review to make a new PR. You can ignore that PR for now. I would > create a new on

Re: Zookeeper 3.10.0 release date

2025-08-19 Thread Christopher
I think most people interpret Java/maven version numbers (x.y.z) as: x = major y = minor z = patch/bugfix I think it's confusing when you say 3.10 is a "major" version. What would you call 4.0.0? A "supremely major" release, perhaps? It's fine to treat a minor release as a substantial change, but

Re: Bump minimum required Java version for building ZK to 11

2025-08-19 Thread Christopher
Sorry for the confusion. I linked that PR mostly for my own reference to review to make a new PR. You can ignore that PR for now. I would create a new one for this. I was getting ahead of myself, because I know that bumping the minimum build version would also include a bump of the Apache parent PO

Re: Bump minimum required Java version for building ZK to 11

2025-08-19 Thread Andor Molnar
Okay. I checked the pull request that you linked and there’s a lot more in that most of which I don’t even understand. I suggest the following: - let’s finish that PR by adding minimum build version of JDK 11 for now, - merge the PR to all active branches: master, branch-3.9 and branch-3.8, - re

[VOTE] Apache ZooKeeper release 3.9.4 candidate 2

2025-08-19 Thread Andor Molnar
This is a release candidate for 3.9.4. This is a minor release with bug- and security fixes. Important to note that due to security issues we’ve upgraded logback to 1.3.15 and slf4j to 2.0.13. No ZooKeeper code changes have been involved in this upgrade, but the SLF4j upgrade was a major versio

[jira] [Created] (ZOOKEEPER-4964) Check permissions individually during admin server auth

2025-08-19 Thread Andor Molnar (Jira)
Andor Molnar created ZOOKEEPER-4964: --- Summary: Check permissions individually during admin server auth Key: ZOOKEEPER-4964 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/ZOOKEEPER-4964 Project: ZooKeeper

Re: Zookeeper 3.10.0 release date

2025-08-19 Thread Andor Molnar
We agreed on that we cut 3.10.0 from the master branch as new major release of ZooKeeper. There’s no plan for 4.0.0 right now. Bumping minimum JDK version to JDK 17 is for 3.10.0 only. I suggested JDK 17, because I’d like to do a major refactoring to upgrade Jetty to the latest (12.1) version a

Re: Zookeeper 3.10.0 release date

2025-08-19 Thread Christopher
I have reservations about bumping the minimum runtime Java version to 17, because I have applications that use ZooKeeper client code that run Java 11. I think a more modest change would be to bump the required build version to 17, but keep the target version at 11. If this is being considered for 4

Re: Bump minimum required Java version for building ZK to 11

2025-08-19 Thread Christopher
Thanks for bringing my suggestion to the mailing list for discussion. I wasn't aware that 17 was being considered. Is there another discussion thread I can read about that? My suggestion could apply with JDK 17 instead of 11. I didn't suggest 17 because I thought 11 would be more acceptable as a