Re: [DISCUSS] Should we move contrib and recipes into separate repos?

2019-05-23 Thread Norbert Kalmar
I agree with Enrico on dropping contrib and keeping recipes. My reasons for dropping contrib projects: - There is not much, if anything, going on around contrib. Even before maven migration, it was a mess (it was duplicated in the tarball, some were built, some were not, kind of randomly). Take for

Re: [DISCUSS] Should we move contrib and recipes into separate repos?

2019-05-22 Thread Ted Dunning
I think that the key question is whether independent releases make sense. If you have two things that must always be released in synchrony, then having them in the same repo is a good idea. If you have two things that are released completely independently, then separate repos make sense. On Wed

Re: [DISCUSS] Should we move contrib and recipes into separate repos?

2019-05-22 Thread Enrico Olivelli
Il mer 22 mag 2019, 09:59 Tamas Penzes ha scritto: > Hi All, > > There is trend among Apache projects to minimise the content of the main > project and move not crucial parts into separate repos. I mostly prefer the > mono-repo style development, but in some cases where the connection between > t

Re: [DISCUSS] Should we move contrib and recipes into separate repos?

2019-05-22 Thread Patrick Hunt
The downside is that you need to separately maintain, support, build infra round, ... and release those repos. They get out of sync with the main repo/releases, etc... Another option is to move them to github or retire them entirely. Patrick On Wed, May 22, 2019 at 12:59 AM Tamas Penzes wrote:

[DISCUSS] Should we move contrib and recipes into separate repos?

2019-05-22 Thread Tamas Penzes
Hi All, There is trend among Apache projects to minimise the content of the main project and move not crucial parts into separate repos. I mostly prefer the mono-repo style development, but in some cases where the connection between the main project and a subproject is weak I find this idea suppor