Re: Are MP3 files now permitted in Fedora packages?

2016-12-11 Thread Peter Robinson
On Sun, Dec 11, 2016 at 3:10 PM, wrote: > I would think that they are now allowed as they should work out of the box. > Maybe we need legal to clarify, then update the guidelines. I would think it would also depend that the actual content in the media is redistributable but then that's the case

Re: Are MP3 files now permitted in Fedora packages?

2016-12-11 Thread Thomas Daede
On 12/11/2016 07:33 AM, Chris Adams wrote: > I would expect if they are provided by upstream, they should be fine. > However, if they are generated during build from some other source, that > won't be acceptable, as MP3 encoding is still not allowed in Fedora. Note also that if you are generating

Re: Are MP3 files now permitted in Fedora packages?

2016-12-11 Thread Chris Adams
Once upon a time, Till Maas said: > Since Fedora now ships a MP3 decoder, does the Code vs Content section > in the Packaging Guidelines[0] now need a update to allow MP3 file or > are MP3 files still not permitted? I would expect if they are provided by upstream, they should be fine. However, if

Re: Are MP3 files now permitted in Fedora packages?

2016-12-11 Thread dennis
I would think that they are now allowed as they should work out of the box. Maybe we need legal to clarify, then update the guidelines. Dennis On 11 December 2016 11:26:38 am GMT+01:00, Till Maas wrote: >Hi, > >Since Fedora now ships a MP3 decoder, does the Code vs Content section >in the Pack

Are MP3 files now permitted in Fedora packages?

2016-12-11 Thread Till Maas
Hi, Since Fedora now ships a MP3 decoder, does the Code vs Content section in the Packaging Guidelines[0] now need a update to allow MP3 file or are MP3 files still not permitted? Kind regards Till [0] https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Packaging:Guidelines#Code_Vs_Content __