Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-10 Thread Eben Eliason
> > Errors ought to be detected as typed, with the text changing > > color at the point where syntax is violated. So this... > > > > 7+5-9*4)-5 > > > > ...would be highlighted starting from the ')' character. > > > This sounds like a good idea, but I think it could be a little tricky > sometimes, s

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-10 Thread C. Scott Ananian
On 9/9/07, Yoshiki Ohshima <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > To reiterate my point, I think "the code behind" should be *ideally* > presented in different ways that different learners can understand. > In Etoys, you can go from visual tile scripting to (say) textual > Smalltalk to the Smalltalk parse

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-10 Thread Reinier Heeres
Albert, Albert Cahalan wrote: > Yoshiki Ohshima writes: > >> Hi, Steve, >> >>> I am a lurker, but this is an interesting discussion. I am a >>> developer in health applications working with current dev release on a >>> B4. Calculate is impressive; Pippy is impressive. They each serve a

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-09 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Ivan, > There were virtually no widespread public systems of education until > the industrial revolution. Once they came about, they came about with > a purpose: creating skilled industrial workers. I would say this part is too much generalization, but,,, > That's broken. The reason the

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread Jim Gettys
On Sat, 2007-09-08 at 22:36 +0200, NoiseEHC wrote: > Wow, fast answer! > > On Sep 8, 2007, at 1:20 PM, NoiseEHC wrote: > >> I tried to run my little tests via this mailing list and there were some > >> kind people who took the time to help me but it turned out that the > >> Geode is below my worst

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread NoiseEHC
Wow, fast answer! > On Sep 8, 2007, at 1:20 PM, NoiseEHC wrote: >> I tried to run my little tests via this mailing list and there were some >> kind people who took the time to help me but it turned out that the >> Geode is below my worst expectations and so requires a lot more tests >> than my pati

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread Ivan Krstić
On Sep 8, 2007, at 1:20 PM, NoiseEHC wrote: > I tried to run my little tests via this mailing list and there were > some > kind people who took the time to help me but it turned out that the > Geode is below my worst expectations and so requires a lot more tests > than my patience. Send me your

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread Ivan Krstić
On Sep 7, 2007, at 5:14 PM, Albert Cahalan wrote: > Dear my. I'm all in favor of supporting the bright kids, but that > suggestion sounds like grade 12 honors at minimum. Based on what? Preconceived notions of kids' capabilities as funneled through modern assembly-line education systems? You've

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread NoiseEHC
> On Sep 7, 2007, at 10:05 PM, Yoshiki Ohshima wrote: > >> You can almost tell that he is pretty much the only guy who is >> interested in supporting outside developers. >> > > That isn't fair. I speak on behalf of the entire OLPC team when I say > that we're extremely interested in supp

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Ivan, > > You can almost tell that he is pretty much the only guy who is > > interested in supporting outside developers. > > That isn't fair. I speak on behalf of the entire OLPC team when I say > that we're extremely interested in supporting outside developers. > There's no question about

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-08 Thread Ivan Krstić
On Sep 7, 2007, at 10:05 PM, Yoshiki Ohshima wrote: > You can almost tell that he is pretty much the only guy who is > interested in supporting outside developers. That isn't fair. I speak on behalf of the entire OLPC team when I say that we're extremely interested in supporting outside develope

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread James Cameron
On Fri, Sep 07, 2007 at 03:34:18PM -0700, Yoshiki Ohshima wrote: > No no. Do you have any reason to believe that cannot be done under > grade 12? (You can't really mean 12th graders... You mean 12 years > old, right?) I'm in Australia. In our school system we use lowest common denominator, cl

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Hi, James, > I'm in Australia. In our school system we use lowest common > denominator, class based teaching ... advancement in knowledge and skill > beyond the plan for the year is socially punished. Wow. Sounds like Japan. > Bright kids learned > to hide their ability. However, even wi

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Albert, > > Again, this is not a criticism toward Reinier, but rather toward the > > fact that keeping up with the rate of change that Sugar and the UI > > guideline is not something a volunteer developer can easily cope with. > > Calculate is in Python, isn't it? Sugar and UI changes are dea

constructivism (Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution)

2007-09-07 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
> > We begin with the hypothesis that any subject can be taught > > effectively in some intellectually honest form to any child at any > > stage of development. -- Jerome Bruner > > > > Sounds more like a statement of faith than a falsifiable hypothesis. It is too bad to see a p

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Mitch, > > Remember the famous quote from Jerome Bruner: > > > > We begin with the hypothesis that any subject can be taught > > effectively in some intellectually honest form to any child at any > > stage of development. > > > > Sounds more like a statement of faith than a fal

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread Mitch Bradley
Yoshiki Ohshima wrote: > > Remember the famous quote from Jerome Bruner: > > We begin with the hypothesis that any subject can be taught > effectively in some intellectually honest form to any child at any > stage of development. > Sounds more like a statement of faith than

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Albert, Oh, good. You weren't simply trying to flame the discussion after all^^; For now, let me just jump to the last part... > > Imagine if the functions that are available in the Calculate "mode" > > (such as sin, sqrt, etc.) are actually defined in a way that kids can > > understand (f

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-07 Thread Albert Cahalan
Yoshiki Ohshima writes: > Hi, Steve, >> I am a lurker, but this is an interesting discussion. I am a >> developer in health applications working with current dev release on a >> B4. Calculate is impressive; Pippy is impressive. They each serve a >> purpose which I think fits into an OPLC evolut

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-06 Thread Yoshiki Ohshima
Hi, Steve, I now understand that the "merger" wouldn't happen in the given timeframe, so the following is just an unconstructive rant... > I am a lurker, but this is an interesting discussion. I am a > developer in health applications working with current dev release on a > B4. Calculate is

Re: Pippy and Calculate - Evolution Solution

2007-09-06 Thread Steve Fullerton
Hi All, I am a lurker, but this is an interesting discussion. I am a developer in health applications working with current dev release on a B4. Calculate is impressive; Pippy is impressive. They each serve a purpose which I think fits into an OPLC evolutionist philosophy. First, there are US t