Well, since I'm the "guy who wrote the code", I'll offer my $0.0001
(my dollars went the way of the market...).
Jeff's memory about why we went to 16 bits isn't quite accurate. The
fact is that we always had 32-bit jobids, and still do. Up to about a
year ago, all of that space was availabl
On Oct 27, 2008, at 5:52 PM, Andreas Schäfer wrote:
I don't know any implementation details, but is making a 16-bit
counter a 32-bit counter really so much harder than this fancy
(overengineered? ;-) ) table construction? The way I see it, this
table which might become a real mess if there are m
I don't know any implementation details, but is making a 16-bit
counter a 32-bit counter really so much harder than this fancy
(overengineered? ;-) ) table construction? The way I see it, this
table which might become a real mess if there are multiple
MPI_Comm_spawn issued simultaneously in differe
How about a variation on that idea: keep a global bitmap or some other
kind of "this ID is in use" table. Hence, if the launch counter rolls
over, you can simply check the table to find a free value. That way,
you can be sure to never re-use a value that is still being used.
So we'd have
I can't swear to this because I haven't fully grokked it yet, but I
believe the answer is:
1. if child jobs have completed, it won't hurt. I think the various
subsystem cleanup their bookkeeping when a job completes, so we could
possibly reuse the number. Might be some race conditions we wo
What's happened if we roll around with the counter ?
george.
On Oct 22, 2008, at 2:49 PM, Ralph Castain wrote:
There recently was activity on the mailing lists where someone was
attempting to call comm_spawn 100,000 times. Setting aside the
threading issues that were the focus of that exc
There recently was activity on the mailing lists where someone was
attempting to call comm_spawn 100,000 times. Setting aside the
threading issues that were the focus of that exchange, the fact is
that OMPI currently cannot handle that many comm_spawns.
The ORTE jobid is composed of two ele
