Re: [riot-devel] 802.15.4 Radio HAL RDM

2020-04-24 Thread Robert Hartung
Good morning RIOT developers, Before giving a review in the mentioned PR, I would like to give some shorts comments on here, that wouldn't fit in the PR. While I really like the new approach to access lower levels directly and making the integration of new network stacks a lot easier, I feel like

Re: [riot-devel] 802.15.4 Radio HAL RDM

2020-04-25 Thread Michael Richardson
I appologize that I have not read the the Pull Request in detail, and thanks to overwork, I'm admitting that I probably won't have the chance. Nor am I an expert in the IEEE 802.15.4 document, where it specifies these "functions". (Maybe Tero Kivinen might help here) My alternative thoughts were

Re: [riot-devel] 802.15.4 Radio HAL RDM

2020-04-25 Thread Michael Richardson
Robert Hartung wrote: > I would like to see a OSI layer model along with common implementations OSI layer documentation has seldom helped people write better code, IMHO. It's a useful abstraction... in the abstract. It's a conceptual model, not a way to structure code. Many have made that