Re: [digitalradio] PSK under ionospheric flutter, was: QEX Article on HF Digital Propagation

2007-10-26 Thread Patrick Lindecker
Hello Vojteck, I think Patrick has a similar mode in MultiPSK, which limits further the character table, making the mode work with even lower S/N. You are right, I have tried PSK10 and PSKAM10. The big problem with these low speeds is the ionospheric Doppler modulation. Without any Doppler in

RE: [digitalradio] PSK under ionospheric flutter, was: QEX Article on HF Digital Propagation

2007-10-26 Thread Rud Merriam
Vojtech, Good points. After some further reflection on the article I am not sure many conclusions can be made from the material beyond its specific results about the modes covered. The various modes are to dissimilar in all aspects to draw any conclusions on whether PSK is better than MFSK, for