Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On 10/6/2015 8:01 PM, Dr. Anthony Gabrielson wrote: PGP is not a monolithic data store although it can interface with one. DoD encryption boxes are not monolithic. It all depends on the model and how trust is defined and established. /etc/passwd is. So is every web service authentication syste

Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Dr. Anthony Gabrielson
I’m not going to go back and forth about this all night… So I’m signing off of this thread after this response else it turns into a classic tl;dr. > On Oct 6, 2015, at 7:55 PM, Rich Pieri wrote: > > On 10/6/2015 7:30 PM, Anthony Gabrielson wrote: >> No… > > Yes. It's a monolithic data store w

Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On 10/6/2015 7:30 PM, Anthony Gabrielson wrote: No… Yes. It's a monolithic data store with every user's identifying credentials in it. It doesn't matter how that data is stored. It doesn't matter what transformations are performed on that data. It's still in one place and the whole thing can

Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Rich Pieri
On 10/6/2015 5:12 PM, Edward Ned Harvey (blu) wrote: I have no idea what RP was talking about, or if there was a point at all, but Anthony, you're right. I know in CBCrypt, there is no basket with all the eggs. Yes, there is. The authenticating server has a piece of information for each user w

Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Edward Ned Harvey (blu)
> From: Discuss [mailto:discuss-bounces+blu=nedharvey@blu.org] On > Behalf Of Dr. Anthony Gabrielson > > > On Oct 6, 2015, at 10:52 AM, Rich Pieri wrote: > > > > The problem isn't encryption or lack thereof. The problem is that the way > > we handle authentication is fundamentally broken. Cen

Re: [Discuss] Fwd: Hey FCC, Don't Lock Down Our Wi-Fi Routers | WIRED

2015-10-06 Thread Chuck Anderson
The current, much reorganized draft is here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1E1D1vWP9uA97Yj5UuBPZXuQEPHARp-AhRqUOeQB2WPk/edit?pli=1 On Mon, Oct 05, 2015 at 06:59:29PM +, Kurt L Keville wrote: > Fwded from Dave Taht... apologies if I am wading into the thread late... >

Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Dr. Anthony Gabrielson
> On Oct 6, 2015, at 10:52 AM, Rich Pieri wrote: > > The problem isn't encryption or lack thereof. The problem is that the way we > handle authentication is fundamentally broken. Centralized authentication is > literally an all eggs in one basket deal. Steal the basket and you get all > the e

Re: [Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Rich Pieri
The problem isn't encryption or lack thereof. The problem is that the way we handle authentication is fundamentally broken. Centralized authentication is literally an all eggs in one basket deal. Steal the basket and you get all the eggs. The problem is compounded by a bass-ackwards verificati

[Discuss] 19,000 person company passwords stolen via HTTPS

2015-10-06 Thread Edward Ned Harvey (blu)
This is the reason why you should care about authentication and encryption happening without exposing passwords or encryption keys to servers. In this case, it was hackers planting a malicious DLL to capture plaintext passwords received during HTTPS login sessions, but there's nothing preventing