Re: [IxDA Discuss] Native vs. Non-native look-and-feel

2008-09-12 Thread Sascha Brossmann
I would like to argue in favour of %u201Cnative%u201D [1]. At least in the regular case: messing around with my motoric memory, my system's default shortcuts, my system's standard widget look/behaviour/positions etc. is not likely to earn you good credits ;-) And, as frequently in design, it is det

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Native vs. Non-native look-and-feel

2008-09-10 Thread Andreas Ringdal
I think it is more important to keep the core functionality and the process of using the application the same on all platforms. I use Evernote both on Windows, OS X, iPhone and Web, and what really annoys me is that it behaves differently. When creating a new note, the windows version automaticall

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Native vs. Non-native look-and-feel

2008-09-09 Thread Jack Leon Moffett
Matt, I think what you are describing here has a lot to do with expectations. As a Mac user, I expect an application that I install and run locally to look and behave like a standard Mac app following Mac OS conventions. When I use an app that has been poorly ported from a Windows version

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Native vs. Non-native look-and-feel

2008-09-09 Thread Jarod Tang
Hi Matt, Take eclipse (www.eclipse.org) example, they have the native look and feel at every platform, but at the same time, keep the interaction (behavior) as uniform as possible, which definitly help it's user experience. But the key here, is 1, first the user experience is uniform 2. second, th

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Native vs. Non-native look-and-feel

2008-09-09 Thread Katie Albers
Hi, Color me confused. What exactly do you mean by native? Do you mean you've designed a different interface for each platform (which is what I usually understand native to mean in this context) or do you mean that you're designing a single interface for all 3 that is native to some unspoken

[IxDA Discuss] Native vs. Non-native look-and-feel

2008-09-09 Thread Matt Doe
Hi everyone, We are charged with the redesign of a cross platform (Windows, Mac and Linux) application. From data we've collected, we know about 93 percent of users are Windows users, 6-7 percent are Mac and the remaining 1 percent are some flavor of Linux. The application was originally written