Re: [IxDA Discuss] Statistics, Facts, Reports on PDF vs. HTML

2008-02-04 Thread Jeff Seager
I think your observations are good ones, Adam, but you may not find the data you're seeking. I've looked for it, too. I know your frustration. In the absence of information about your specific use case, some food for thought: * For the inexperienced user, well-formed HTML/XHTML is designed to do

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Statistics, Facts, Reports on PDF vs. HTML

2008-02-04 Thread Adam Connor
Thanks for the input everyone. Jeff: I completely realize that Adobe has made a lot of effort to include things like accessibility, and I commend them for it. The issues I've observed though, is that for a general audience, expectancy changes when users are presented with a PDF on the web, they

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Statistics, Facts, Reports on PDF vs. HTML

2008-02-03 Thread Bruce Esrig
Keep in mind that you might be able to get both. If the source is written in DITA XML, you can output topics in whatever combination you find necessary, and in multiple formats, including HTML and PDF. The barrier to general use is significant, since you have to put in place special software

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Statistics, Facts, Reports on PDF vs. HTML

2008-02-02 Thread pauric
Adam:I myself believe very strongly that PDFs have a certain place on the web and that mimicking web functionality is not it, but the more ammo I go in with the better. I accept that pov but until you've exported a sketch/wireframe/interactive wireframe to pdf and sent it to a client or used it

[IxDA Discuss] Statistics, Facts, Reports on PDF vs. HTML

2008-02-01 Thread Connor, Adam
I am working to make the case to some of my company's IT professionals that the decision to go with PDF delivery for certain reports rather than HTML is a bad one. I've read all of Nielson's articles on PDFs as well as rebuttals by various individuals (where they only seem to point out that PDFs

Re: [IxDA Discuss] Statistics, Facts, Reports on PDF vs. HTML

2008-02-01 Thread Jeff Seager
Great question! The decision _may not_ be a bad one, actually, depending on the specifics. A lot of it depends on how you've set up the PDF, which may be somewhat inaccessible by default. Adobe has made some significant effort to help with these concerns, but it's something many people don't