Re: [Distutils] Symlinks vs API -- question for developers

2008-10-17 Thread Greg Ewing
Toshio Kuratomi wrote: So once again, I think this boils down to these questions: if we have a small library whose sole purpose is to abstract a data store so you can find out where a particular non-code file lives on this system will you use it? As part of the stdlib? Yes, I'd use it. -- Gre

Re: [Distutils] Symlinks vs API -- question for developers

2008-10-17 Thread Paul Moore
2008/10/17 Barry Warsaw <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: >> So once again, I think this boils down to these questions: if we have a >> small library whose sole purpose is to abstract a data store so you can >> find out where a particular non-code file lives on this system will you >> use it? > > I would. I ap

Re: [Distutils] Symlinks vs API -- question for developers

2008-10-17 Thread Ian Bicking
Toshio Kuratomi wrote: So I have a question for all the developers on this list. Philip thinks that using symlinks will drive adoption better than an API to access package data. I think an API will have better adoption than a symlink hack. But the real question is what do people who maintain p

Re: [Distutils] Symlinks vs API -- question for developers

2008-10-17 Thread Barry Warsaw
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On Oct 17, 2008, at 1:32 PM, Toshio Kuratomi wrote: 7) Philip says that the reason pkg_resources does not see widespread adoption is that the developer cost of using an API is too high compared to __file__. I don't believe that the difference be

[Distutils] Symlinks vs API -- question for developers

2008-10-17 Thread Toshio Kuratomi
So I have a question for all the developers on this list. Philip thinks that using symlinks will drive adoption better than an API to access package data. I think an API will have better adoption than a symlink hack. But the real question is what do people who maintain packages think? Since Phi

[Distutils] [patch] executable Scripts on windows

2008-10-17 Thread anatoly techtonik
Hello, I would like to discuss a patch that adds executable .bat files for scripts installed with distutils. As a windows user with several Python versions installed I often create shortcuts for Python applications that were installed using distutils. But I also have to navigate to Scripts/ direc