Re: [dmarc-ietf] Jim Fenton's review of -04

2014-12-21 Thread Dave Crocker
On 12/20/2014 11:18 PM, Jim Fenton wrote: >> DMARC asserts authenticity of the rfc5322.From field domain name. >> That's a distinct semantic increment over anything SPF or DKIM do on >> their own. > > What it does is different enough from SPF and DKIM that I think it's > overloading the term

Re: [dmarc-ietf] Jim Fenton's review of -04

2014-12-21 Thread Stephen J. Turnbull
Jim Fenton writes: > Hi, Dave - > > On 12/19/2014 02:30 PM, Dave Crocker wrote: > > [2.4 Out of Scope] > >> Bullet 10: Again, DMARC doesn't do authentication, even for domains; it > >> relies on other authentication mechanisms. > > I originally thought this, too, but in fact DMARC does do