[DNSOP] Dnsdir early review of draft-ietf-dnsop-dnssec-validator-requirements-01

2022-11-23 Thread James Gannon via Datatracker
Reviewer: James Gannon Review result: On the Right Track Reviewer: James Gannon Review Result: On the right track As this is an early review (And also my first ietf review so please feel free to offer feedback on its usefulness!) its a mix of general comments and some more detailed comments on se

[DNSOP] Subject: request for adoption: draft-edns-presentation

2022-11-23 Thread libor.peltan
Hi DNSOP, we have prepared a specification document (see below), which fills a gap that appears to be missing currently — The EDNS(0) textual and JSON format. It also fixes a "specification bug" in an existing and related RFC. We believe this draft is pretty much complete and have a first PoC

Re: [DNSOP] Working Group Last Call for draft-ietf-dnsop-dnssec-validator-requirements

2022-11-23 Thread Vladimír Čunát
OK, thanks.  The changes are certainly improvements, in my eyes.  Below I'll further clarify what I meant. 4033 indicates it does not make much sense to keep a RRSIG whose validity period has expired ( TTL > Validity period). Yes, I should stress that I do agree with trimming TTL of whole RR