[DNSOP] Dnsdir telechat review of draft-ietf-dnsop-dns-error-reporting-07

2023-12-10 Thread James Gannon via Datatracker
Reviewer: James Gannon Review result: Ready Hi Folks, I have reviewed 07 against the feedback on both the -04 and -06 and the document seems to be in good shape to move forward at this time. Thank you for the comprehensive feedback to all the reviewers and god engagement on some of the topics. _

[DNSOP] Dnsdir last call review of draft-ietf-dnsop-rfc8499bis-09

2023-08-28 Thread James Gannon via Datatracker
Reviewer: James Gannon Review result: Ready Hi Folks, I am the assigned DNSDIR reviewer for this draft. Thank you for a well-written draft that appears to be very comprehensive Some very minor comments that are non-blocking. Section 1: Personal Preference: The intro section seems to be a little

[DNSOP] Dnsdir early review of draft-ietf-dnsop-dns-error-reporting-04

2023-06-07 Thread James Gannon via Datatracker
Reviewer: James Gannon Review result: Ready Hi Folks, I am the assigned DNSDIR reviewer for this draft. Thank you for a well-written draft that appears comprehensive and easy to understand from an implementor's perspective. I found no major or minor issues and I believe the draft is ready to progr

[DNSOP] Dnsdir early review of draft-ietf-dnsop-dnssec-validator-requirements-01

2022-11-23 Thread James Gannon via Datatracker
Reviewer: James Gannon Review result: On the Right Track Reviewer: James Gannon Review Result: On the right track As this is an early review (And also my first ietf review so please feel free to offer feedback on its usefulness!) its a mix of general comments and some more detailed comments on se