Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-10 Thread Edward Lewis
A re-ordering of the previous message happens here: On 7/9/15, 13:45, DNSOP on behalf of hellekin dnsop-boun...@ietf.org on behalf of helle...@gnu.org wrote: *** Should IETF use social media to expand their reach? (@ietf? @dnsopwg?) Oddly enough, ICANN does this, an in fact the ICANN staff

Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-09 Thread hellekin
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA512 On 07/08/2015 08:36 AM, Suzanne Woolf wrote: It further seems to me that an attempt to list names that are currently in the public root zone or might someday be in the public root zone has a high risk of being simply backwards if the purpose

Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-08 Thread Hugo Maxwell Connery
: Thoughts on the top level name space Colleagues, As we pursue this discussion, I think it would be helpful to focus on attributes that are visible and relevant from the perspective of DNS operators, with an eye towards guidance we might provide to them and applications developers

Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-08 Thread Paul Hoffman
secretary-hat on On Jul 8, 2015, at 8:06 AM, Hugo Maxwell Connery h...@env.dtu.dk wrote: I posit that continued inaction on the question of Does the .onion case fit the RFC6761 mechanism actually weakens the reputation of the IETF, and certainly that of DNSOP. I acknowledge that it is

Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-08 Thread Edward Lewis
On 7/8/15, 7:36, Suzanne Woolf suzworldw...@gmail.com wrote: For example, the distinction between gTLDs and ccTLDs is of great importance to ICANN and to participants in its decisions, but of less obvious relevance to an application developer or DNS operator who sees only name that gets a

Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-08 Thread Rubens Kuhl
Em 08/07/2015, à(s) 14:33:000, Edward Lewis edward.le...@icann.org escreveu: On 7/8/15, 7:36, Suzanne Woolf suzworldw...@gmail.com wrote: For example, the distinction between gTLDs and ccTLDs is of great importance to ICANN and to participants in its decisions, but of less obvious

Re: [DNSOP] perspective Re: Thoughts on the top level name space

2015-07-08 Thread Edward Lewis
On 7/8/15, 13:51, DNSOP on behalf of Rubens Kuhl dnsop-boun...@ietf.org on behalf of rube...@nic.br wrote: Em 08/07/2015, à(s) 14:33:000, Edward Lewis edward.le...@icann.org escreveu: On 7/8/15, 7:36, Suzanne Woolf suzworldw...@gmail.com wrote: For example, the distinction between gTLDs