Re: DOCBOOK-APPS: DTD vs. XML Schema

2003-03-14 Thread Dave Pawson
At 13:50 14/03/2003 +0100, Gour wrote: Jirka Kosek ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > From theoretical point of view RNG is cool schema language especially > for grammar-based document types like DocBook. AFAIK there is zero > support for RNG in XML content creation tools (editors). And you will > have

Re: DOCBOOK-APPS: DTD vs. XML Schema

2003-03-14 Thread Gour
Jirka Kosek ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > From theoretical point of view RNG is cool schema language especially > for grammar-based document types like DocBook. AFAIK there is zero > support for RNG in XML content creation tools (editors). And you will > have same problem with entities as in XML sc

Re: DOCBOOK-APPS: DTD vs. XML Schema

2003-03-14 Thread Jirka Kosek
Gour wrote: > > Be you, I would stay with DTD for DocBook documents. > > And what about Relax NG? >From theoretical point of view RNG is cool schema language especially for grammar-based document types like DocBook. AFAIK there is zero support for RNG in XML content creation tools (editors). An

Re: DOCBOOK-APPS: DTD vs. XML Schema

2003-03-14 Thread Gour
Jirka Kosek ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: > Be you, I would stay with DTD for DocBook documents. And what about Relax NG? Sincerely, Gour -- Gour [EMAIL PROTECTED] Registered Linux User #278493

Re: DOCBOOK-APPS: DTD vs. XML Schema

2003-03-14 Thread Jirka Kosek
"Olson, Dave -Systems" wrote: > > Could someone give me a list of the advantages and disadvantages of using > the DocBook DTD(s) vs. a DocBook XML Schema? I'm just starting a DocBook DTD is more mature and proven technology. I think that XML schema for DocBook is just early release for testing.

DOCBOOK-APPS: DTD vs. XML Schema

2003-03-13 Thread Olson, Dave -Systems
Could someone give me a list of the advantages and disadvantages of using the DocBook DTD(s) vs. a DocBook XML Schema? I'm just starting a documentation conversion project, using Cocoon (Xalan is XSLT engine). I've never used either a DTD or XML Schema, so using either form of XML technology invo