Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-05 Thread John Arthorne
> From: Tom Schindl > > I'm not a committer on the runtime project. It I be able to get commit > rights there. You are a committer already Tom. Runtime was merged into Platform UI. John ___ e4-dev mailing list e4-dev@eclipse.org https://dev.eclipse.or

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-05 Thread Tom Schindl
On 03.09.13 15:38, John Arthorne wrote: > I agree leaving it in e4 repository is not the right long term home. You > interpreted the silence to Dirk's post to mean that nobody wants it. > Another way to interpret that is nobody objected so you can go ahead and > release it in a core runtime bundle.

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-04 Thread Tom Schindl
es at runtime so I would be curious >> to hear their input on that. Have you guys talked to them about your >> approach? >> >> John >> >> >> >> >> From:Tom Schindl >> To:e4-dev@eclipse.org, >> Date:

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-04 Thread Lars Vogel
curious to hear their input on that. Have you guys talked to them about >> your approach? >> >> John >> >> >> >> >> From:Tom Schindl >> To:e4-dev@eclipse.org, >> Date:09/03/2013 09:07 AM >> Subject:Re:

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-04 Thread Dirk Fauth
ur approach? > > John > > > > > From:Tom Schindl > To: e4-dev@eclipse.org, > Date:09/03/2013 09:07 AM > Subject:Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new > message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern > Sent

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-04 Thread Daniel Rolka
From: Wim Jongman To: E4 Project developer mailing list , Date: 09/04/2013 11:26 AM Subject: Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern Sent by: e4-dev-boun...@eclipse.org +1 On Wed, Sep 4, 2013 at 10:58 AM, Lars Vogel wrote

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-04 Thread Wim Jongman
so I would be >> curious to hear their input on that. Have you guys talked to them about >> your approach? >> >> John >> >> >> >> >> From:Tom Schindl >> To:e4-dev@eclipse.org, >> Date:09/03/2013 09:07 AM >

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-04 Thread Lars Vogel
To: e4-dev@eclipse.org, > Date:09/03/2013 09:07 AM > Subject:Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new > message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern > Sent by:e4-dev-boun...@eclipse.org > -- > &

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-03 Thread John Arthorne
d at this. They are the experts in supporting multiple locales at runtime so I would be curious to hear their input on that. Have you guys talked to them about your approach? John From: Tom Schindl To: e4-dev@eclipse.org, Date: 09/03/2013 09:07 AM Subject:Re: [e4-dev] Eclips

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-03 Thread Lars Vogel
Hi Tom, AFAIK the e4 project is for hosting innovative new technologies like this new translation approach which I really like. I agree that the bundle name should get changed. Maybe this project should also be moved to its own e4 Git repo to separate it from the tools but IMHO e4 is the right pl

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-03 Thread Tom Schindl
Hi, The problem is that currently this whole stuff is the tools-namespace and I think it is not very logical that something like this in tools whereas it clearly is a runtime kind of thing. The same argument goes for the IResource stuff beside that the you'll notice that there are also the bridge

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-03 Thread Lars Vogel
Hi, If I understand your email correctly you are suggesting to move the current implementation to another Git repo. What is the problem with leaving it in the e4 tools repository? You have commit rights there and if Dirk want to work on it, we can also suggest him as e4 committer. Best regards,

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-09-03 Thread Tom Schindl
Hi, >From the lack of feedback it seems the platform is not really interested in this feature. Still we - e(fx)clipse - would like to advertise this way of NLS to our (e4) users. I talked to Dirk and he's no objections moving it to efxclipse-runtime where our core bundles only depend on e4-di (no

Re: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-08-12 Thread Keimel, Christoph
your blog, the migration is easy enough. Keep up the great work! Smile Christoph Von: e4-dev-boun...@eclipse.org [mailto:e4-dev-boun...@eclipse.org] Im Auftrag von Dirk Fauth Gesendet: Montag, 12. August 2013 11:21 An: e4-dev@eclipse.org Betreff: [e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new me

[e4-dev] Eclipse Internationalization with the new message extension and the Eclipse translation pattern

2013-08-12 Thread Dirk Fauth
Hi everybody, I'm not sure if everybody is aware of the message extenstion that was created by Tom Schindl and extended by me. I would say it is an evolution of the existing internationalization stuff in Eclipse, that introduces a lot more flexibility. Currently it is contributed to the e4.tools