Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-21 Thread Jerry Dallal
dennis roberts wrote: At 02:11 PM 8/20/00 -0500, Herman Rubin wrote: It is necessary to simultaneously consider all consequences of the proposed action in all states of nature. every now and then, herman tosses in this dart ... but, i have never once heard him say

Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-21 Thread Alan McLean
Many people - including me - have been saying this for at least 20 years. The trouble is that people have different opinions on what the 'concepts' are. Plus maths is in many ways the best way to explain some of the concepts. And then you need to relate the maths to the methodological

Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-20 Thread Herman Rubin
In article [EMAIL PROTECTED], Sheila King [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Several people have pointed out, in response to my original question, that xbar is the point estimator and xbar +/- ME is an interval of points. Sorry I wasn't more clear in my original post. I was aware of that difference

Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-20 Thread dennis roberts
At 02:11 PM 8/20/00 -0500, Herman Rubin wrote: It is necessary to simultaneously consider all consequences of the proposed action in all states of nature. every now and then, herman tosses in this dart ... but, i have never once heard him say what the heck this means ...

Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-15 Thread Sheila King
Point estimation, for mu: Use x bar (sample mean) as estimator for x bar. If the size of the data sample is at least thirty, and the population standard deviation is not known, use the data sample's standard deviation as an approximation thereof. Compute the SE for x bar which is population std

Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-15 Thread dennis roberts
if you have X bar .. that IS the point estimate OF mu ... (it is one value) if you have calculated some confidence interval ... then that is the INTERVAL estimate of mu ... (this is a range of values within which ... you hope that mu falls ... ) to build the CI ... you start with a point

Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-15 Thread Sheila King
Several people have pointed out, in response to my original question, that xbar is the point estimator and xbar +/- ME is an interval of points. Sorry I wasn't more clear in my original post. I was aware of that difference pointed out above. The problem is, the text I'm using states in the

Re: Point vs. Interal estimation

2000-08-15 Thread dennis roberts
unfortunately, most books are not clear on everything ... hopefully, the book will deal with basic issues and concepts reasonably well ask students the following: say you were at the race track and ... you have picked your favorite horse for race #7 ... 1. how many minutes do you think it