RE: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Alan Bloom
On Thu, 2008-02-28 at 11:06, Darwin, Keith wrote: > I did my comparisons a few years ago so what follows is my recollection > of my tests. ... > Drake 2B vs. K2 > > The Drake is a fabulous sounding rig. Very clean, smooth, sweet. > Unfortunately, it has a very aggressive AGC so you'll never he

RE: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread David Walker
:08 -0700 From: "Gary D Krause" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers To: "Elecraft" , Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain;charset=iso-8859-1;format="flowed" Since the K3 is at the top of the list now and the K2 isn&

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread K4tmc
Gary, Based on your scenario, it would take me a few hours operating a contest to make a decision, but I feel confident that I could pick the better receivers out of the group, "for my purposes." Now, this may not be the same selection that someone else makes. However, if you have a large

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread S Sacco
Very broad topic here. One thing that you might very well notice about the different receivers, is how much different they sound, one from another, even in a situation where you're listening to a single signal on an otherwise clear band. Audiophiles would know the correct buzz-words, but tube rec

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread n2ey
-Original Message- From: Gary D Krause <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> I've been wondering how the numbers really affect what we hear. If a ham were to sit down in front of all the top rigs, >blind folded and not allowed to touch them, would he or she be able to pick out the one with the best rece

RE: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Darwin, Keith
-Original Message- From: Darrell Bellerive [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Keith, I would be interested in reading about your observations on the differences between receivers. Please consider posting them to the reflector. - I did my comparisons a few years ago so w

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Vic K2VCO
Gary D Krause wrote: Since the K3 is at the top of the list now and the K2 isn't far behind, I've been wondering how the numbers really affect what we hear. If a ham were to sit down in front of all the top rigs, blind folded and not allowed to touch them, would he or she be able to pick out t

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Gary D Krause
Thanks Keith, that's good to know. I only have two other rigs to compare my K2 with and they are older rigs that I bought in the eighties. I believe they are both single conversion designs and I swear that I can sometimes hear weak signals better on them than on my K2 but, the K2 has much better

[Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Gary D Krause
--- the forwarded message follows --- ___ Elecraft mailing list Post to: Elecraft@mailman.qth.net You must be a subscriber to post to the list. Subscriber Info (Addr. Change, sub, unsub etc.): http://mailman.qth.net/mailman/listinfo/elecraft

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Darrell Bellerive
Keith, I would be interested in reading about your observations on the differences between receivers. Please consider posting them to the reflector. Darrell On Thursday 28 February 2008 09:01, you wrote: > I've done this, or as close to it as I can get. Yes, there is a big > difference. > >

RE: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Darwin, Keith
I've done this, or as close to it as I can get. Yes, there is a big difference. I hook up 2 rigs to the same antenna and then feed their audio outputs (speaker outs) into a mixing board. I adjust the audio to give the best S/N ratio on the rig and then trim each channel on the mixer to get both

Re: [Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Don Wilhelm
Gary, Those better numbers will allow you to copy weaker signals than a receiver with a poorer numbers. So there is something to it other than just chasing numbers. Will the average ragchewing ham notice a difference - maybe, but that is not the type who typically dig for weak signals. The DX

[Elecraft] Chasing the numbers

2008-02-28 Thread Gary D Krause
Since the K3 is at the top of the list now and the K2 isn't far behind, I've been wondering how the numbers really affect what we hear. If a ham were to sit down in front of all the top rigs, blind folded and not allowed to touch them, would he or she be able to pick out the one with the best r