Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-17 Thread W7TEA
What held me back from completing my K3 order was the small front panel. I played with one in Aptos and decided that while I'd much prefer a larger panel with more space between the knobs, the K3 would work. I've most recently owned an Orion, an Omni VI+ and an Omni VII. I tend to like big

[Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread George
Modern radios do malfunction in such a way that repair of them is likely beyond the capability of most owners, unless the radio came from Elecraft. Should such an event occur with your radio, would you rather pack and ship back to the factory a brick (Icom, etc), or a feather (A K3 module). T

Re: Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread Art
g - or not - on the air. 73 Art Message: 51 Date: Fri, 16 May 2008 12:26:48 -0400 From: Bill Tippett <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns K6XT wrote: >I note that the 7800 first appeared with something like a 6KHz first IF filter, got hammere

[Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread Bill Tippett
K6XT wrote: >I note that the 7800 first appeared with something like a 6KHz first IF filter, got hammered in the press, eham etc. for lousy close-in performance, and quickly added a 3KHz 1st IF filter option. Bzzzt...you forgot Icom's advertising formula! Their 6 kHz filter is actually 1

Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread David Ferrington, M0XDF
same here, I was going for the FT-2000 before the K3 announcement - that changed a lot of things, including having the space to put it on my desk -- If you must play, decide on three things at the start: the rules of the game, the stakes, and the quitting time. -Chinese Proverb On 16 May 2008

RE: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread Nelson Moyer
I've been following the 'big gun' thread with interest. I'm astonished that this group seems to imply that 'big gun' status depends upon the radio you own, rather than the amplifiers and antennas you use. Most rigs today put out between 100-200 watts, regardless of price. DX'ing and contesting succ

RE: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread Shane White
I think that's an unreasonable statement Joe. Please have another read of my initial post. I didn't make any such assumption, I merely questioned the relative cost and performance of some radios. No 73's for you. Shane. Joe Stofko-2 wrote: > > Hi Dave, > > Right you are! Actually, Sh

RE: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread Joe Stofko
Hi Dave, Right you are! Actually, Shane's thinking is a bit flawed. He equates performance with product price and weight. And, neither should be part of the criteria. We have, sadly, become the victims of marketing. We are slammed with it every day. The product that costs more, MUST (so

Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread G4ILO
Simon Brown (HB9DRV) wrote: > > IC-7800 height or even a tad more. I'm not a fan of making radios as small > as possible. Perhaps not, but a lot of people don't have the luxury of large rooms to operate in. With the box room I have to use, I wouldn't have the space for an IC-7400 even if I coul

Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns

2008-05-16 Thread Simon Brown (HB9DRV)
IC-7800 height or even a tad more. I'm not a fan of making radios as small as possible. Simon Brown, HB9DRV -- From: "David Ferrington, M0XDF" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> How many units high? On 16 May 2008, at 09:43, Simon Brown (HB9DRV) wrote: I

Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns [OT]

2008-05-16 Thread Geoffrey Downs
Simon, they might have been even more delighted with a K3! (We shall never know.) If being sold out is a measure of satisfaction, I shouldn think the K3's order backlog would put it at the top of the list :-) 73 to all Geoff G3UCK - Original Message - From: "Simon Brown (HB9DRV)

Re: [Elecraft] The K3 in comparison to the Big Guns [OT]

2008-05-16 Thread Simon Brown (HB9DRV)
IMO one area where the IC-7700 and co. win out is in ergonomics, especially for those of us who are members of the Terminally Bewildered club (tired eyes, colour blindness). Given the extra real estate this may seem like a daft comparison, but the FTDX-9000's tuning knob(s) and the IC-7700 / IC