On 11/30/05, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
At 01:51 PM 11/27/2005, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote:At 07:11 PM 11/23/2005, Rob Brown wrote:Yes, but all it shows is the winner, and only if that candidate is
the condorcet winner.What if the winner is not a condorcet winner?Then the matrix
Briefly replying to two people's comments:
Rob Brown wrote:
-snip-
I believe that condorcet elections intentionally ignore strength
of opinion information for the exact same practical reason. Since
there is no way to avoid collecting some strength of opinion
information (while still
On 12/1/05, Steve Eppley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Briefly replying to two people's comments:Rob Brown wrote:-snip- I believe that condorcet elections intentionally ignore strength of opinion information for the exact same practical reason. Since
there is no way to avoid collecting some strength
Steve Eppley wrote:
Hi,
[Rob Brown suggested I post his unintentionally private message
to me and my reply. Here they are.]
Rob wrote to me:
On 12/1/05, Steve Eppley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I agree with both of Rob's messages so far on this topic
except for one sentence,
On 12/1/05, Paul Kislanko [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Ah, but you contradict yourself. See
below.
Sorry if you don't want me mentioning borda, but the only way to get
around what you see as wrong is by doing exactly what borda does. And
that is bad.
Borda isn't the only way topreserve rank
