Re: [EM] Amnon Rubinstein's Proposal for Electoral Reform in Israel

2006-04-30 Thread Markus Schulze
Dear Doreen Dotan, I have just written a paper about all those types of vote management strategies. See section 4 of this paper: http://home.versanet.de/~chris1-schulze/schulze2.pdf Markus Schulze election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info

[EM] Proportional Condorcet Voting

2006-04-30 Thread Antonio Oneala
All of the proportional condorcet methods I've heard of so far rely on STV to some extent. While this may be useful for ease of use (I'm not sure, I still don't completely understand them) in CPO-STV and sequential STV, it isn't really the best way to apportion the votes, as it introduces some of

Re: [EM] Proportional Condorcet Voting

2006-04-30 Thread Dan Bishop
Antonio Oneala wrote: All of the proportional condorcet methods I've heard of so far rely on STV to some extent. PSC-CLE doesn't rely on STV. However, the simplicity comes at a price: 80: ABCDEF 40: DEFABC Winners of a 3-seat election are A, B, D. 10: X1ABCDEF 10: X2ABCDEF 10: X3ABCDEF 10: