Re: [EM] A modified Random Ballot that supports compromising

2006-07-01 Thread Simmons, Forest
Jobst, how about this slight variation on your suggestion? 1. Ranked ballots with truncation. 2. Draw a ballot at random. 3. Draw additional ballots at random until there is one that has at least one ranked candidate in common with the first ballot, or until all ballots are exhausted.

Re: [EM] another proposal for a voting system

2006-07-01 Thread Simmons, Forest
I like RPR. The additional control that this gives to voters might make voters less squimish about proxy. Forest winmail.dat election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info

Re: [EM] candidate withdrawal IRV - what should the rules be?

2006-07-01 Thread Simmons, Forest
I like the idea of giving candidates the option of withdrawal before each potential elimination. It seems true that most candidates would be more reluctant to withdraw than their supporters might want, but if no candidate withdraws, then IRV with withdrawal reduces to plain IRV, no harm