Re: [EM] Mass Candidates

2006-07-03 Thread Dave Ketchum
TOO MANY candidates. Voters cannot sort such a field in any reasonable effort. About their best choice is hearing from a handful of candidates and sorting among them. My vote, as about always, is for Condorcet, permitting ranking a little more than 3, though 3 is enough to satisfy most. DO p

Re: [EM] Mass Candidates

2006-07-03 Thread Stephane Rouillon
Hi Dave, any system that would leave a default value for unvalued/unranked/unapproved candidates would help. Personnaly, I would suggest: A) Let the voter precise the score, rank or state of all unexpressed preferences; B) I favor preference-style ballots over simple approbational ballots; C) I fa

Re: [EM] Mass Candidates

2006-07-03 Thread David Cary
--- dave smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi All, > > I need help in determining what voting system would be best for the > following criteria: > > ~500 candidates > ~1000 voters > 1 winner Can you tell us something about the context of the election? Who are the voters, who/what are the cand

Re: [EM] Mass Candidates

2006-07-03 Thread Jan Kok
Seems unreasonable to expect the voters to know 500 candidates. The winner would likely be someone who is well known to many of the voters, though not necessarily in a way that makes the winner qualified for the job (Schwartzenegger), or the winner might be very popular with a plurality of the vote

Re: [EM] Mass Candidates

2006-07-03 Thread raphfrk
From: dave smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > I need help in determining what voting system would be best for the > following criteria: > > ~500 candidates > ~1000 voters > 1 winner > > I was going to do a form of PV, but limit the number of ranks to 3. > The problem with this is that what if there are mo

[EM] Mass Candidates

2006-07-03 Thread dave smith
Hi All, I need help in determining what voting system would be best for the following criteria: ~500 candidates ~1000 voters 1 winner I was going to do a form of PV, but limit the number of ranks to 3. The problem with this is that what if there are more candidates than voters, and the voters de