At 09:13 AM 10/29/2006, Chris Benham wrote:
>CB: No.I see "group decision making process" as spread out along a
>continuum with "informal consensus"
>at one end and civil war or violent "mob rule" at the other. Abd
>sees elections as (in his view undesirably)
>substituting for consensus and wants
Hello,
--- Chris Benham <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> a écrit :
> Range has no real "majority-rule" related guarantees, except a very
> unimpressive weakened
> version of Minimal Defense that means that for a majority to block the
> election of X they
> must both give X a minimum rating and some other ca
Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote:
At 11:34 PM 10/27/2006, Chris Benham wrote:
Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote:
That is, healthy group decision process follows certain general
principles. The Majority Criterion neglects an important part of this.
That is beca
Dear Antonio,
you wrote (23 Oct 2006):
> In a single-seat election a perfect race would be between two opponents.
> If you vote for one you are definitely voting against the other one and
> the worst of the two will always be eliminated. In a two-seat election,
> it follows, a perfect election w
