Re: [EM] Candidate Strengths and Significance of Defeats

2006-10-26 Thread Juho
The S(X) function seems to lead to search of the worst path (of length that corresponds to the number of iteration cycles) of defeats leading to candidate X. This seems to make losing to bad losers worse than losing to some good candidates. But the function seems to get less interesting whe

[EM] Candidate Strengths and Significance of Defeats

2006-10-26 Thread Simmons, Forest
It seems to me that when estimating the strength of candidate X on the basis of a pairwise comparison with candidate Y, we should take into account the strength of candidate Y ; if Y is a weak candidate, then a large margin of victory by X over Y may not be as significant as a small marg