Re: [EM] Rob Richie's criticism of Approval Voting

2006-06-13 Thread Jonathan Lundell
At 2:18 PM -0600 6/13/06, Jan Kok wrote: >One bit of help I could use: Is anyone familiar with the article Rob >mentions in this paragraph? > >> Jack Nagel, a UPenn professor, has an important new article out >>this year called "Burr's Dilemma" that goes into how this flaw >>played out in the 17

Re: [EM] Rob Richie's criticism of Approval Voting

2006-06-13 Thread Jonathan Lundell
At 2:18 PM -0600 6/13/06, Jan Kok wrote: >mentions in this paragraph? http://w3.uniroma1.it/mathdemocr/nagel.zip (powerpoint) > > Jack Nagel, a UPenn professor, has an important new article out >this year called "Burr's Dilemma" that goes into how this flaw >played out in the 1796 and 1800 pre

[EM] Rob Richie's criticism of Approval Voting

2006-06-13 Thread Jan Kok
I encourage people who want to know the details of what is going on with Denver's election reform to subscribe to the irv-l list via irvdenver.org . The traffic is about 2 or 3 posts per day. The message attached below is Rob's reply to a nice post by Mahendra Prasad, included below. (Thanks, Mahe