Re: [EM] Strategy free method proposal

2005-12-19 Thread rob brown
On 12/17/05, Simmons, Forest <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote: Rob, in my experience typically when there is a Condorcet Cycle there is no Approval Strategy A style equilibrium of the kind you posit in your second message on this topic.It had been under the understanding that there will always be at leas

Re: [EM] Strategy free method proposal

2005-12-17 Thread Simmons, Forest
Rob, in my experience typically when there is a Condorcet Cycle there is no Approval Strategy A style equilibrium of the kind you posit in your second message on this topic. However, the method you propose in your earlier message might indeed approach an approval strategy A configuration as a

Re: [EM] Strategy free method proposal

2005-12-15 Thread rob brown
Sorry for replying to my own post, but it occured to me that there is a more straightforward (although possibly less efficient) way of finding the "Approval Equilibrium".  If there are multiple Approval Equilibriums, it will find all of them, and if none, it can determine that as well.  (I'm pretty

[EM] Strategy free method proposal

2005-12-15 Thread rob brown
I'm submitting the following method that I believe to be strategy-free.  There is no randomness involved (although like any method without randomness, it is subject to true ties).  I believe it is immune to unresolvable cycles, with the exception of true ties.  (I have not proven this last point) I