Re: [Election-Methods] Matrix voting and cloneproof MMP questions

2008-07-10 Thread Markus Schulze
Dear James Gilmour, you wrote (10 July 2008): If you are going to mess about with MMP to the extent that you suggest in the hope of making some significant improvements to what is basically a very poor voting system, why not just adopt STV-PR and do the job properly? When you promote pure

Re: [Election-Methods] Matrix voting and cloneproof MMP questions

2008-07-10 Thread James Gilmour
Markus Schulze Sent: Thursday, July 10, 2008 8:45 AM If you are going to mess about with MMP to the extent that you suggest in the hope of making some significant improvements to what is basically a very poor voting system, why not just adopt STV-PR and do the job properly?

Re: [Election-Methods] USING Condorcet

2008-07-10 Thread Kevin Venzke
Hi Juho, A quick response. --- En date de : Mar 8.7.08, Juho [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit : Ok, this is a good concrete example scenario. The votes are of course simplified. Surely there would be also considerable number of other kind of opinions than these three. But let's see first