Though it was by accident that I posted my Electowiki Symmetrical ICT revision to EM, still, having done so, I should also post to EM what was missing from the version that I posted to EM. In that version, I left out the very thing that was needed to make Symmetrical ICT work as intended:
After the line: X beats Y iff (X>Y) + (X=Y)B > (Y>X) + (X=Y)T, ...this should follow:: ...except that two candidates can't beat eachother. If, by the above beat-condition line, two candidates beat eachother, then only one of them beats the other. The one that beats the other is the one that is ranked over the other on more ballots than vice-versa. [end of added clause] That change has, of course, already been made to the Electowiki article. Mike Ossipoff ---- Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info