Re: [EM] Kevin's other posting on votes-only criteria vs preference criteria.

2011-11-19 Thread Markus Schulze
Hallo, Mike Ossipoff wrote (18 Nov 2011): > Not many methods meet SDSC. ABucklin and MDD,ABucklin do. > But difficultly-attainable criteria are useful for describing > advantages offered by only a few methods. Also the Schulze method meets SDSC. Markus Schulze Election-Methods mailing li

Re: [EM] Kevin's other posting on votes-only criteria vs preference criteria.

2011-11-18 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
Kevin: You said: In practice [preference-mentioning criteria] usually have to be translated into votes-only criteria in order to figure out how to use or test them. [endquote] So what? Regardless of your procedure for applying the criteria, my criteria apply to all methods. Votes-only criter