Re: [EM] Why I think IRV isn't a serious alternative 3

2008-12-24 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 10:29 PM 12/23/2008, Kevin Venzke wrote: (in response to my post) This is missing the point. There is no implication anywhere that a zero-info strategy is supposed to be usable by real voters. If we use zero-info strategy to judge a method, and that strategy doesn't apply to real voters, w

Re: [EM] Why I think IRV isn't a serious alternative 3

2008-12-23 Thread Kevin Venzke
Hello, --- En date de : Lun 22.12.08, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax a écrit : > At 12:56 AM 12/21/2008, Kevin Venzke wrote: > > --- En date de : Ven 19.12.08, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax > a écrit : > > [starts with Venzke, then my response, then his] > > > > Mean utility is supposed to be naive, and it > is >