[Election-Methods] Best electoral system under real circumstances

2007-11-19 Thread Diego Renato
I've read in this list that possibly the worst electoral system used is Brazilian open list PR. In this year, Brazilian Congress discuted the change of electoral law to closed lists, single member plurality or MMP. Presidents, Governors and Mayors are elected by top-two runoff. I think this method

Re: [Election-Methods] Best electoral system under real circumstances

2007-11-19 Thread Juho
I'll compare the Brazilian open list method to a somewhat corresponding case, open list based parliamentary election in Finland and the plans to improve it. In Finland the smallest districts have now 6 seats. That is considered a problem since having both districts with lots of seats (max

Re: [Election-Methods] Best electoral system under real circumstances

2007-11-19 Thread Dave Ketchum
I restrict my commenting to Condorcet. On Mon, 19 Nov 2007 23:56:32 +0200 Juho wrote: ... > > Single member: Does this mean a dual party system based on single > seat districts? Is that what Brazil wants? (I don't yet.) > > MMP: More complex than open list. What is the rationale? Maybe > i