[Election-Methods] RE : Re: Why monotonicity? (was: Smith +mono-add-top?)

2008-01-10 Thread Kevin Venzke
Hi, --- daniel radetsky [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit : That would be nice, but all the evidence to date shows that it is impossible. No-one has yet devised a voting system that incorporates all of the desirable features. The evidence does not show that this is impossible. If nobody has

Re: [Election-Methods] RE : Re: Why monotonicity? (was: Smith +mono-add-top?)

2008-01-10 Thread daniel radetsky
On Jan 10, 2008 7:46 PM, Kevin Venzke [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Plenty of incompatibilities have been proven at least with rank ballot methods. Well, there you go. I doubt there's good reason to be optimistic about getting around many of these incompatibilities by changing the ballot type.