Re: [EM] Conceding Victory

2004-04-07 Thread James Green-Armytage
Forest Simmons <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >(5) Nader says, "Why not? Let's take it to the Supreme Court." > >(6) The Supreme Court says the tradition of conceding has withstood all >challenges, but has never been spelled out. Let's spell it out in the way >that will serve the best interest of the

[EM] Conceding Victory

2004-04-07 Thread Forest Simmons
There is a long tradition of candidates conceding victory before all of the votes are counted, once they lose hope of winning. Has anybody ever challenged this tradition in court? I remember that at one point Gore conceded to Bush, and then he changed his mind, so ultimately the Supreme Court app

Re: [EM] Bucklin

2004-04-07 Thread Forest Simmons
On Wed, 7 Apr 2004, Forest Simmons wrote: > On Tue, 6 Apr 2004, Rob LeGrand wrote: > > > Here's a question I thought about quite a bit a while ago but never posted > > until now that there's talk of Bucklin on the list: Which candidate should > > win the following Bucklin election? > > > > 25:Bro

Re: [EM] Bucklin

2004-04-07 Thread Forest Simmons
On Tue, 6 Apr 2004, Rob LeGrand wrote: > Here's a question I thought about quite a bit a while ago but never posted > until now that there's talk of Bucklin on the list: Which candidate should > win the following Bucklin election? > > 25:Brown>Jones>Davis>Smith > 26:Davis>Smith>Brown>Jones > 49:J

Re: [EM] PR Condorcet algorithm implemented as experiment

2004-04-07 Thread Adam H Tarr
>I implemented the PR-enforcing Condorcet algorithm I described in my recent >mail to this list, as part of the CIVS voting web service. If you would like >to try it out (and give me some testing!), visit the following URL and vote on >the "ice cream assortment" election: > >http://www5.cs.cornell

Re: [EM] Is strategic voting a bad thing, really?

2004-04-07 Thread Forest Simmons
On Mon, 5 Apr 2004, Bart Ingles wrote: > > In general, it's a good thing. However the NEED or INCENTIVE for > strategic voting is sometimes a bad thing, if it results in Duvergerian > equalibria (Plurality, Runoff, Instant Runoff), or in artificial ties or > "random" outcomes (Borda). ... or if

[EM] PR Condorcet algorithm implemented as experiment

2004-04-07 Thread Andrew Myers
I implemented the PR-enforcing Condorcet algorithm I described in my recent mail to this list, as part of the CIVS voting web service. If you would like to try it out (and give me some testing!), visit the following URL and vote on the "ice cream assortment" election: http://www5.cs.cornell.edu/~