Re: [EM] Can Writeins ever win

2005-07-09 Thread bql
On Sun, 10 Jul 2005, Dave Ketchum wrote: Pretty rare, but confusion made it happen near here last year: Came deadline for petitions, and there were none, for the candidates had been given a wrong date. So EVERY voter had to writein to vote for their choice for that office. There was a rece

[EM] Can Writeins ever win

2005-07-09 Thread Dave Ketchum
Pretty rare, but confusion made it happen near here last year: Came deadline for petitions, and there were none, for the candidates had been given a wrong date. So EVERY voter had to writein to vote for their choice for that office. -- [EMAIL PROTECTED]people.clarityconnect.com/webpages3/

Re: [EM] Write-ins break condorcet summability

2005-07-09 Thread bql
On Sun, 10 Jul 2005, Dave Ketchum wrote: I believe I have the answer for Condorcet, and that you should be able to build on this for ratings. I also think of voting at multiple precincts, doing an array at each precinct, and summing the arrays for total district. May have to scan each ballot

Re: [EM] Write-ins break condorcet summability

2005-07-09 Thread Dave Ketchum
I believe I have the answer for Condorcet, and that you should be able to build on this for ratings. I also think of voting at multiple precincts, doing an array at each precinct, and summing the arrays for total district. May have to scan each ballot for new names at start of its processing,

[EM] Write-ins break condorcet summability

2005-07-09 Thread bql
How do you compare a new entry all the ones that came before? Having a policy for incomplete ballots isn't good enough because it doesn't compare a new name to the other names on ballots before the first ballot to include a new write-in candidate. So, there must always be a first pass through a

[EM] RE: Lotteries undefeated "in median"

2005-07-09 Thread Simmons, Forest
Jobst, I'm still digesting this. I'm always interested in potentially good "lottery methods." Here's my latest attempt: Voters first submit approvals, and the candidates are listed in order of approval. Each voter then submits a number between 1 and the number of candidates (to be used

[EM] Lotteries undefeated "in median"

2005-07-09 Thread Jobst Heitzig
Dear folks! Some time ago I reported here upon the "Condorcet Lottery", a method which determines the winner by drawing from a special probability distribution (=lottery) among a special subset of the candidates (the so-called Bipartisan set). The special property of that method was that for every