[EM] Why it doesn't matter if prefer means anything

2005-10-10 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
I've posted a precise definition of "prefer", but actually it doesn't matter what "prefer" means. In fact it doesn't matter if "prefer" means anything, for the purpose of my criteria. Some or all of my criteria use the word "prefer", as do some of their supporting definitions. First, let m

[EM] A precise abstract definition of "prefer"

2005-10-10 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
Though I've told why, for the purpose of my criteria (and Steve's criteria) it doesn't matter what "prefer" means, and, in fact, though I've told why it doesn't matter if "prefer" doesn't mean anything, some may be uncomfortable about the fact that I haven't posted a precise definition of "prefer

[EM] Power Truncation

2005-10-10 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
EM listmembers-- This is the last of 4 initial messages that I intend to send to the Condorcet mailing list, about MDDA, to introduce it, its advantages, properties, and possible enhancements, to the Condorcet mailing list: I suggest that the best rank-method proposal is the ordinary MDDA sta

[EM] Statue language for MDDA

2005-10-10 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
The bulk of this definition is the general definition of rank-balloting. The actual definition of MDDA is no wordier than the brief definition that I've already posted. Rank-balloting definitions: To rank a candidate means to assign to that candidate a positive integer which will be referre

[EM] Deluxe MDDA

2005-10-10 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
Deluxe MDDA is just MDDA with a separate Approval cutoff, an opportunity for the voter to indicate his/her lowest approved ranking. That means that one can approve some, but not all, candidates, while ranking all of the candidates. Obviously deluxe MDDA receives more information from voters.

[EM] A more briefly-defined method with the best mix of properties

2005-10-10 Thread MIKE OSSIPOFF
EM members-- This is a copy of a message that I intend to post at the Condorcet mailing list. I have just finished requesting membership in that mailing list. I don't know how often it takes to be approved for membership, and so I'd like to post, to EM, three messages that I intend to post to