Re: [EM] Re: What respected IRVists are saying about Condorcet, Approval, etc

2005-03-11 Thread Eric Gorr
James Green-Armytage wrote: When exactly did Lindsay post this, and under what subject heading? I'll reply on that list, when I find out. Looks like I was partially mistaken. Jim Lindsay does post to the CA IRV list (as does Sccott Menzies & Emily McPhail, to whom his was replying directly, whic

Re: [EM] Re: What respected IRVists are saying about Condorcet, Approval, etc.

2005-03-10 Thread Dave Ketchum
On Thu, 10 Mar 2005 16:07:53 -0800 Ted Stern wrote: On 9 Mar 2005 at 11:06 PST, Eric Gorr wrote: I attached a document, which I came across recently, being distributed by an IRVist (Jim Lindsay) to fellow IRV supporters and found it quite interesting. Thought others might be interested as well i

Re: [EM] Re: What respected IRVists are saying about Condorcet, Approval, etc

2005-03-10 Thread James Green-Armytage
I had some free time this afternoon, and for some reason I decided to reply to that Jim Lindsay pdf you posted. I live in California, so I might as well try to get in touch with some of these Cali-IRV people to see what they're about. When exactly did Lindsay post this, and under what subject he

Re: [EM] Re: What respected IRVists are saying about Condorcet, Approval, etc.

2005-03-10 Thread Eric Gorr
Ted Stern wrote: Who is Jim Lindsay? Where is he located? I know someone by that name. I came across him and his document via this group: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/InstantRunoffCA/ I also found it interesting that he implied Borda was partially immune from the spoiler effect...this is the f

[EM] Re: What respected IRVists are saying about Condorcet, Approval, etc.

2005-03-10 Thread Ted Stern
On 9 Mar 2005 at 11:06 PST, Eric Gorr wrote: > > I attached a document, which I came across recently, being distributed > by an IRVist (Jim Lindsay) to fellow IRV supporters and found it quite > interesting. > > Thought others might be interested as well in what is being said about > Condorcet,