James,
--- James Gilmour <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> a écrit :
> > (Gary prefers closed party list because he says it reduces the
> > incentives for similar candidates to compete against each other
> > by promising pork to their constituency. ...
>
> The difference between closed party list and STV-
> Steve Eppley > Sent: Thursday, March 18, 2004 4:06 AM
> Except that if the election will be counted by hand, then the
> choice of variation of STV-PR is constrained: It must forbid
> each voter from ranking candidates as equally preferred (except
> at the bottom "truncated" part of her order
Stephane Rouillon > Sent: Tuesday, March 16, 2004 7:12 PM
> STV is a good model. Could you
> elaborate on the debate aspects?
I'm not sure what your meant by "the debate aspects", but you may find what you are
looking for on
Fairshare's website:
www.fairsharevoting.org
Click on the "The story
Hi,
Stephane Rouillon a écrit :
> James Gilmour a écrit :
-snip-
> > Computerisation, with electronic voting, may be the way
> > forward, but there are still some problems to be overcome.
> > But these problems relate to the voting method (electronic
> > without an audit trail) and NOT to the v
James Gilmour a écrit :
> Stephane, sorry if I sounded a little harsh in my one-word response. My problem is
> that, as an
> active campaigner for practical reform, I encounter comments about the complications
> and "problems"
> of STV-PR counting almost every week from those who are opposed
Stephane wrote:
> First I meant long not hard and second if you've got the
> (wo)manpower it is not really long. I'm sorry it was the
> feeling I got after resolving alone 12 elections of 15
> candidates and 15 voters. So please everyone, I remove that
> opinion, STV is perfectly feasible by h
I apologize: my mistake.
First I ment long not hard and second if you've got the (wo)manpower it is not really
long.
I'm sorry it was the feeling I got after resolving alone 12 elections of 15 candidates
and 15 voters.
So please everyone, I remove that opinion,
STV is perfectly feasible by hand
