On Fri, 2005-09-09 at 18:58 -0700, Simmons, Forest wrote:
If MinMax(AO) turns out to satisfy clone winner, then I think it would
be the best AWP proposal, because it would be simpler to explain than
Beatpath or Ranked Pairs, and no harder to explain than Copeland,
especially when you take
Forest,
--- Simmons, Forest [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit :
Yes, this is the measure of defeat strength used in AWP, but here's the
question: Is AWP
based
on River the same as AWP based on MinMax?
I think the answer for AWP is no. All these methods using WA are the same
probably
because any
Forest,
--- Simmons, Forest [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit :
--- Simmons, Forest [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit :
This brings up a question. How good is MinMax(Approval Against)?
By Approval Against I mean number of ballots on which X is approved and
Y is not.
I call this approval
I wrote ...
Yes, this is the measure of defeat strength used in AWP, but here's the
question: Is AWP based
on River the same as AWP based on MinMax?
Somewhat surprisingly, the answer to the analogous question for winning
approval as a measure
of defeat strength is affirmative:
