Re: [EM] Election districts (was bicameral design poll)

2004-01-07 Thread Ernest Prabhakar
Hi Matt, Interesting. I've been wondering what the best alternative to PR is for dealing with gerrymandering, and whether there was a mathematical definition that would provide a reasonable definition of locality yet be mostly immune from political biasing. On Jan 6, 2004, at 4:49 PM, [EMAIL

RE: [EM] Election districts (was bicameral design poll)

2004-01-06 Thread Sampo Syreeni
On 2004-01-06, James Gilmour uttered: >And we here in the UK already know that virtual districts are not worth a >second thought, at least, not here. [...] Locality and community are very >important. I agree, but for a different reason. If we impose democratic rule on a group of people, we're ess

RE: [EM] Election districts (was bicameral design poll)

2004-01-06 Thread James Gilmour
> James wrote > > I respect your sincerity, but you are not living in the > real world of practical > > politics. Electors want real districts, not virtual districts. Matt wrote > Maybe, but if there is a solution to a real problem then we > cannot know if the solution will be adopted without