RE: [EM] STV: who could ask for anything more?

2003-07-14 Thread Craig Carey
Below, a reply to Mr Venkze: Ballot papers inside of ballot papers; Approval vs monotonicity -- At 2003-07-13 19:14 +0100 Sunday, James Gilmour wrote: ... >> What are the flaws of STV? > >Like several other systems, i

RE: [EM] STV: who could ask for anything more?

2003-07-13 Thread James Gilmour
I agree with much that James G-A wrote, but would add some observations. James Green-Armytage wrote (in part): > Personally, I wouldn't lump STV and party list together > on the same > level. I would argue that STV is a real leap forward from > party list in a > number of ways. I would g