Re: Supermajority

1998-04-28 Thread DEMOREP1
Just getting 2/3 (i.e. 2:1) majorities to propose U.S. or State constitutional amendments has proven difficult enough. Most major reform amendments have come about only due to some major crisis. Such as - the 12th Amdt after the chaos of the 1800 election, the 13th, 14th and 15th Amdts due to t

Re: Exaggerated opinions

1998-04-28 Thread Markus Schulze
Dear David, you wrote (28 Apr 1998): > The tempted voters are faced with a game in which their minimax > strategy is to vote according to their true preferences. > > Conjecture A: Condorcet/Dodgson meets this. > > Conjecture B: Only Condorcet/Dodgson meets this. (Not so sure about > this one!

Re: Exaggerated opinions

1998-04-28 Thread David Marsay
Dear Markus In response to your posting of 25 April. As far as I can see, your criteria are necessary, but not sufficient to give your: > The reason: It is very difficult and risky to manipulate > with irrelevant candidates or with order-reversal, because > > a) there must be a suitable candi