Re: Basic principle? [EM]

1998-06-12 Thread Mike Ositoff
On Fri, 12 Jun 1998, Fillard Rhyne wrote: > >MS> But my point is: The assertion that a "basic democratic principle" > >must always > >MS> select the candidate preferred by a majority - is merely that, an > >assertion. > >MS> I do not believe it is a necessary or even useful component of a valid

Re: Basic principle? [EM]

1998-06-12 Thread Fillard Rhyne
>MS> But my point is: The assertion that a "basic democratic principle" >must always >MS> select the candidate preferred by a majority - is merely that, an >assertion. >MS> I do not believe it is a necessary or even useful component of a valid >group >MS> decision-making method. >MO> Wrong. The d

Basic principle?

1998-06-12 Thread Saari
In a message dated 98-06-12 06:42:47 EDT, Mike O writes: > ...my >basic democratic principle that says "If a majority rank >A over B, then if we choose A or B, it should be A". Part of the problem with these discussions is the variety of opinions held, without rigorous analysis. The above is a

Basic principle?

1998-06-12 Thread Saari
In a message dated 98-06-12 06:42:47 EDT, Mike O writes: > ...my >basic democratic principle that says "If a majority rank >A over B, then if we choose A or B, it should be A". Part of the problem with these discussions is the variety of opinions held, without rigorous analysis. The above is a