Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-29 Thread Randall Clague
On Mon, 29 Sep 2003 22:42:16 +0100, Ian Woollard <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >Doug Jones wrote: > >> The price of LOX kinda drives a stake through the heart of >> airbreathing concepts... > >It's not all about the propellent price anyway, jet engines are >reasonably cheap and TSTO may well be opt

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-29 Thread Ian Woollard
Doug Jones wrote: The price of LOX kinda drives a stake through the heart of airbreathing concepts... It's not all about the propellent price anyway, jet engines are reasonably cheap and TSTO may well be optimal with an airbreathing first stage... Put it another way- tell that to Rutan. _

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Pierce Nichols
At 06:31 PM 9/26/2003 -0400, Henry Spencer wrote: You're confusing propaganda with facts. :-) There's no shortage of implicit claims that using less oxidizer will lower propellant costs too. This does not stand up to even a moment's inspection, but since when has that ever stopped people from ma

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Henry Spencer
On Fri, 26 Sep 2003, Pierce Nichols wrote: > >Actually, needing less oxidizer is frequently cited as a big advantage of > >air-breathing propulsion, with the implication that it should lower costs. > > Yes, but not because you are buying less oxidizer. It's the buying > less tankage and

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Pierce Nichols
At 06:03 PM 9/26/2003 -0400, Henry Spencer wrote: On Fri, 26 Sep 2003, Pierce Nichols wrote: > >The price of LOX kinda drives a stake through the heart of airbreathing > >concepts... > > The price of LOX was never a serious driver for looking into air > breathing propulsion, so I don't rea

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Henry Spencer
On Fri, 26 Sep 2003, Pierce Nichols wrote: > >The price of LOX kinda drives a stake through the heart of airbreathing > >concepts... > > The price of LOX was never a serious driver for looking into air > breathing propulsion, so I don't really see how that follows. Actually, needing le

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Henry Spencer
On Fri, 26 Sep 2003, David Weinshenker wrote: > > N2O4 18.50(various MON concentrations) > > RFNA 26.25 > > H2O2 70% 1.05(Higher conc TBD) > > MMH 61.00 > > Hmmm $26/lb for nitric acid? and $61 for MMH? > That seems awful high for commodity chemicals that the > rocket in

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread John Carmack
At 02:42 PM 9/26/2003 -0700, you wrote: Doug Jones wrote: > > Stumbled across this today- > http://www.desc.dla.mil/DCM/Files/MissileFuelPricesFY04.pdf > > Bulk prices converted to $/lb- > > Prop $/lb > LOX 0.0405 ($81/ton) > N2O4 18.50(various MON concentrations) > RFNA 26.2

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Pierce Nichols
At 02:42 PM 9/26/2003 -0700, David Weinshenker wrote: Hmmm $26/lb for nitric acid? and $61 for MMH? That seems awful high for commodity chemicals that the rocket industry has been buying in bulk for years... I'd guess that most of that cost is due to the fact that both those chemi

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Pierce Nichols
At 12:50 PM 9/26/2003 -0700, Doug Jones wrote: The price of LOX kinda drives a stake through the heart of airbreathing concepts... The price of LOX was never a serious driver for looking into air breathing propulsion, so I don't really see how that follows. -p "No science with

Re: [ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread David Weinshenker
Doug Jones wrote: > > Stumbled across this today- > http://www.desc.dla.mil/DCM/Files/MissileFuelPricesFY04.pdf > > Bulk prices converted to $/lb- > > Prop $/lb > LOX 0.0405 ($81/ton) > N2O4 18.50(various MON concentrations) > RFNA 26.25 > H2O2 70% 1.05(Higher conc TB

[ERPS] Interesting price list

2003-09-26 Thread Doug Jones
Stumbled across this today- http://www.desc.dla.mil/DCM/Files/MissileFuelPricesFY04.pdf Bulk prices converted to $/lb- Prop $/lb LOX 0.0405 ($81/ton) N2O4 18.50(various MON concentrations) RFNA 26.25 H2O2 70% 1.05(Higher conc TBD) MMH 61.00 RP1 0.46($3/ga