Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread nichomachus
On Apr 14, 6:26 pm, Saibal Mitra <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Citeren nichomachus <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > > > > In the description of the quantum immortality gedanken experiment, a > > physicist rigs an automatic rifle to a geiger counter to fire into him > > upon the detection of an atomic dec

Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread nichomachus
On Apr 14, 9:21 pm, Russell Standish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Further to this, to say that the 2nd law is falsified, we'd have to > have circumstances where the less likely outcome ocurred more > frequently than the more often. (ie entropy decreases more often than > it increases). But this

Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread Russell Standish
Further to this, to say that the 2nd law is falsified, we'd have to have circumstances where the less likely outcome ocurred more frequently than the more often. (ie entropy decreases more often than it increases). But this begs the question of what we mean by likelihood of outcome, if not related

Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread Stathis Papaioannou
On 15/04/2008, Michael Rosefield <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > No, it just means no-one's put enough stress on the 2nd Law yet :) > > Besides, it's not so much a law as a guideline. Well, a strong statistical > tendency As Michael pointed out, the 2nd law is a statistical law, which says that

Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread Michael Rosefield
No, it just means no-one's put enough stress on the 2nd Law yet :) Besides, it's not so much a law as a guideline. Well, a strong statistical tendency On 15/04/2008, nichomachus <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > In the description of the quantum immortality gedanken experiment, a > physicist r

Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread Saibal Mitra
Citeren nichomachus <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > In the description of the quantum immortality gedanken experiment, a > physicist rigs an automatic rifle to a geiger counter to fire into him > upon the detection of an atomic decay event from a bit of radioactive > material. If the many worlds hypothe

Re: Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread Saibal Mitra
Citeren nichomachus <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > > In the description of the quantum immortality gedanken experiment, a > physicist rigs an automatic rifle to a geiger counter to fire into him > upon the detection of an atomic decay event from a bit of radioactive > material. If the many worlds hypothe

Quantum Immortality = no second law

2008-04-14 Thread nichomachus
In the description of the quantum immortality gedanken experiment, a physicist rigs an automatic rifle to a geiger counter to fire into him upon the detection of an atomic decay event from a bit of radioactive material. If the many worlds hypothesis is true, the self-awareness of the physicist wil

Re: An Equivalence Principle

2008-04-14 Thread Bruno Marchal
Youness, hmmm I am not sure Perhaps a duality, or a Galois connection of some sort. I'm afraid that an *equivalence* would show up only in the case where "I" am the "world" or comp is false or in the case where the comp level of substitution is infinitely low, roughly speaking. In that