RE: possible solution to modal realism's problem of induction

2005-07-30 Thread Brian Holtz
eed to the same extent as the sorts of guarantees we get in thermodynamics and quantum mechanics, then that's scientific enough for me. :-) Brian Holtz Yahoo! Inc. blog: http://knowinghumans.net book: http://humanknowledge.net

RE: possible solution to modal realism's problem of induction

2005-07-28 Thread Brian Holtz
ves me) than non-nice functions.  Etc . But all that is required to resolve the induction objection is that not-nice universes are usually not noticeable as such to their inhabitants. I guess I need to learn some more transfinite mathematics before I'll be able to understand how (whethe

RE: possible solution to modal realism's problem of induction

2005-07-24 Thread Brian Holtz
y irregular worlds, even if apparently irregular worlds predominate over worlds that in fact contain neither apparent nor non-apparent irregularities. I'm guessing I would have this intuition even if weren't attracted to an information-theoretic approach to defining or specifying wor

RE: possible solution to modal realism's problem of induction

2005-06-27 Thread Brian Holtz
at apparently regular worlds should predominate over apparently irregular worlds, even if apparently irregular worlds predominate over worlds that in fact contain neither apparent nor non-apparent irregularities. I've yet to hear (or at least understand) anything that contradicts this intuition. Brian Holtz blog: http://knowinghumans.net book: http://humanknowledge.net

RE: possible solution to modal realism's problem of induction

2005-06-15 Thread Brian Holtz
Title: Message Alex Pruss wrote: Remember that I am working in David Lewis's framework.  Each world is a physical object: a bunch of matter, connected together spatiotemporally.  So I do not need to work with specifications, but with concrete chunks of stuff.  There is nothing fur

Re: possible solution to modal realism's problem of induction

2005-06-14 Thread Brian Holtz
Title: Message Hi everyone (in this world and all relevantly similar ones :-),   I like the solution to the Induction / Dragon / Exploding Cow problem that I see in work by Malcolm, Standish, Tegmark, and Schmidhuber. So I forwarded references to Alexander Pruss, whose dissertation raises th