Fwd: Better Than the Chinese Room

2014-02-15 Thread David Nyman
-- Forwarded message -- From: David Nyman david.ny...@gmail.com Date: 15 February 2014 23:45 Subject: RE: Better Than the Chinese Room To: Craig Weinberg whatsons...@gmail.com Can you give me a principled distinction between reproducing and copying? David Sent from my Windows

Re: Fwd: Better Than the Chinese Room

2014-02-15 Thread Russell Standish
Reproducing (especially WRT self-reproduction) involves development: executing a program that describes the thing being copied to create a copy of that thing. Whereas copying merely looks at the original object, and recreates it. The program (if it can be called a program) doesn't contain any